The Essential Guide to Nonprofit Insurance: Safeguarding Your Organization and Leadership

The Essential Guide to Nonprofit Insurance: Safeguarding Your Organization and Leadership

---

---

In our previous post, we discussed why Directors and Officers (D&O) insurance is critical for nonprofit organizations, helping protect board members and executives from personal liability in the face of legal claims. While D&O insurance is vital, it is just one part of a comprehensive risk management strategy. Nonprofits face a variety of risks, and protecting your organization requires a mix of different coverage types. In this post, we’ll break down the key types of insurance every nonprofit should consider to protect its operations, employees, leadership, and assets.

1. Directors & Officers (D&O) Insurance: Protecting Leadership

As we discussed earlier, D&O insurance protects the personal assets of board members and executives in case they are sued for decisions made in their leadership roles. Nonprofit boards are just as vulnerable to litigation as for-profit businesses, with potential claims ranging from wrongful termination to discrimination, breach of fiduciary duty, and more. The right D&O coverage ensures that board members can lead without fear of personal financial ruin from legal challenges.

However, D&O insurance is just one piece of the puzzle. Let’s explore the additional coverage options that nonprofits need to consider.

2. Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI): Shielding Against Workplace Claims

Nonprofit organizations, like any other employer, are at risk for employment-related claims. EPLI is designed to protect your nonprofit against lawsuits stemming from workplace issues. These claims can include:

• Discrimination (age, race, gender, disability, etc.)
• Harassment (sexual or otherwise)
• Wrongful termination or retaliation
• Failure to promote
• Negligent hiring or supervision

The cost of defending an employment practices lawsuit, even if it’s frivolous or without merit, can be significant. Employment practices claims are particularly common in nonprofit organizations that employ staff or rely on a large number of volunteers. While nonprofits are generally considered to be more “people-oriented,” they must still comply with federal and state employment laws.

EPLI typically covers both the organization and its employees, including management and board members, making it an essential addition to your risk management strategy.

3. Cyber Liability Insurance: Protecting Against Data Breaches and Cyberattacks

With nonprofits increasingly relying on technology to handle donations, volunteer information, and employee data, the risk of cyberattacks and data breaches is higher than ever. Cybercriminals target nonprofits just as much as they target for-profit companies, often because nonprofits may have weaker cybersecurity defenses.

Cyber Liability Insurance provides coverage for data breaches and cyberattacks, including:

• Data Breach Costs: Covers the expenses associated with informing affected individuals, providing credit monitoring services, and covering legal fees.
• Network Security Failures: If a cyberattack disrupts your organization’s operations (such as ransomware attacks), this coverage can help with recovery costs.
• Liability Claims: If a third party suffers damages as a result of your nonprofit’s cybersecurity breach (e.g., a vendor or donor), this insurance can help with claims and settlements.
• Regulatory Fines: Many states have laws requiring nonprofits to protect personal data. If your nonprofit fails to comply with data protection laws, cyber insurance may cover fines and penalties.

In an increasingly digital world, cyber liability is becoming a crucial part of any nonprofit’s risk management plan.

4. General Liability Insurance: Protecting Against Everyday Risks

Every nonprofit, no matter how small, should have General Liability Insurance (GLI). This coverage protects the organization from claims that could arise from accidents, injuries, or property damage that occur on its premises or as part of its activities. For example:

• Slip and Fall Injuries: If someone is injured while visiting your office or attending an event, GLI can cover medical expenses and legal fees.
• Bodily Injury: If an employee or volunteer causes an injury while performing duties for the organization, GLI covers legal costs and settlements.
• Property Damage: If your nonprofit rents or owns property, general liability can cover the costs of damage to the building or equipment.

General Liability is one of the most basic but necessary types of coverage for nonprofits.

5. Crime Insurance: Protecting Against Internal Fraud and Theft

Nonprofits, just like any business, can fall victim to employee theft or fraud. Whether it’s the misappropriation of funds, embezzlement, or other forms of internal theft, crime insurance helps protect your organization’s assets.

This coverage often includes:

• Employee Dishonesty: Protects against theft or embezzlement by staff members.
• Theft of Money or Property: Covers stolen funds or physical assets from the nonprofit’s premises or during business activities.
• Forgery or Alteration of Documents: If a fraudster alters documents or checks to divert funds, this insurance helps cover the loss.

Nonprofits are particularly vulnerable because they often operate with limited financial oversight, relying on volunteers and staff to manage finances. Crime insurance helps fill that gap and provides peace of mind.

Protecting nonprofits requires more than just D&O insurance. As nonprofits face a wide array of risks—ranging from workplace lawsuits to cyberattacks and fraud—having a comprehensive insurance package is essential for long-term sustainability and peace of mind. The right mix of insurance coverage, including D&O, EPLI, cyber, general liability, and more, ensures that nonprofits can weather any storm.

At Apogee, we specialize in nonprofit insurance and work with over 30 markets to find the best coverage for your organization. If you’re ready to secure your nonprofit with the right insurance, or if you have questions about what types of coverage you need, reach out to our team today!